INTRODUCTION
The Allahabad High Court has drawn a sharp distinction between a formal marriage (Nikah) under personal law and the concept of a live-in relationship. The Court ruled that the “puberty exception” which traditionally allows Muslim minors to enter into a valid marriage cannot be used as a shield to legalize live-in arrangements for those under the age of 18. This judgment reinforces the supremacy of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012 and the Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, 2006 over personal law in non-marital contexts.
BACKGROUND
The ruling originated from a petition for protection filed by a young couple (an interfaith or intra-faith pair, involving a Muslim minor girl). The petitioners sought directions from the Court to prevent police and family from interference, arguing that under Muslim Personal Law, the girl had attained puberty and was therefore “major” in the eyes of her personal law, making her eligible to choose her partner and live with him.
However, the State opposed the petition, contending that a live-in relationship is not a “marriage”. They argued that without the sanctity of a Nikah, the girl remains a “child” under the statutory laws of the land, specially the POCSO Act, which defines any person below 18 as a minor regardless of their religion or biological maturity.
KEY POINTS
- The Court observed that live-in relationships are a social reality but they do not enjoy the same status as that of marriage under the personal laws. Personal law exceptions are strictly for the purpose of solemnizing marriage and cannot be extended to facilitate “extra marital” cohabitation.
- The Bench emphasized that the POCSO Act is a “special enactment” designed to protect minors. Personal Law cannot be used to bypass the criminal liability that arises when a minor is involved in a sexual relationship outside of a legally recognized marriage.
- Article 21of the Constitution protects the right to life and liberty, the Court however, clarified that this right is not absolute and does not permit violation of existing secular statutes intended to protect the welfare of children.
- The Court observed that in Islamic law, physical intimacy outside of marriage (Zina) is not recognized. Therefore, a petitioner cannot claim protection under Muslim Personal Law for a relationship that the personal law itself does not sanction.
RECENT DEVELOPMENT
In the recent case of Shajiya Parveen And Another V. State of U.P. WRIT-C No. 469 of 2026, decided on 4 May, 2026, the Allahabad High Court dismissed the plea of protection. The Court observed that allowing such petitions would open a wide gate for many others where the protective statute of the POCSO Act would be rendered toothless by citing personal laws.
The Court directed the local police to ensure that the minor was returned to her legal guardians or shifted to a shelter home, stating that her “consent” to a live-in relationship is legally irrelevant so long as she is under 18 years of age. This follows a series of recent 2026 rulings where the court has refused to grant protection to “married” persons in live-in relationships without a formal divorce, providing for a broader judicial trend towards tightening the legal definitions of legal cohabitations.
CONCLUSION
The Allahabad High Court’s ruling acts as a critical firewall between traditional personal laws and modern statutory protections for minors. By refusing to extend the “puberty exception” to live-in relationships, the judiciary has prioritized the safety and legal status of children over religious interpretations of maturity. This judgement makes sure that the POCSO Act remains a secular shield for all children in India, effectively closing a loophole that previously allowed for the potential exploitation of minors under the guise of “personal liberty”.
“PRIME LEGAL is a National Award-winning law firm with over two decades of experience across diverse legal sectors. We are dedicated to setting the standard for legal excellence in civil, criminal, and family law.”
WRITTEN BY: LISHIKA BATRA
