Case name: M/s S.S. Exports v. M/s ARK Shipping Co. Ltd.
Case number: Writ Petition No. 21581 of 2026 (GM-CPC)
Date of judgment: 3 November 2026
Court: High Court of Karnataka at Bengaluru
Quorum / Bench: Single Judge Bench – Hon’ble Smt. Justice Lalitha Kanneganti.
Facts of the case:
The case concerns M/s ARK Shipping Co. Ltd, which is a South Korean company that got a Foreign Arbitral Award in their favor dated 21 February 2005, arbitration seat being in Singapore. To enforce the said Foreign Arbitral Award in India, ARK Shipping filed an Execution Petition in India before the Bengaluru Executing Court via its Power of Attorney holder Mr. A.Z. Mookhtiar. The judgment debtor M/s S.S. Exports, made several attempts to object to the enforcement of the Foreign Arbitral Award in the court and these objections were unsuccessful, they were filed in Karnataka High Court as well as in the Supreme Court. In 2026, S.S. Exports again made objections and claimed that ARK Shipping did not submit the Board Resolution that empowered its Power of Attorney and initiated Execution Petition, and thus such authority was not established. But the application of S.S. Export was rejected by the Executing Court on 1 July 2026. Dissatisfied with this decision, S.S. Exports approached Karnataka High Court and objected to the rejection of their application.
Legal provisions:
- Article 227 of the Indian Constitution – Gives the power to the High Court to oversee the subordinate courts and inquire whether the actions of the courts have been legal.
- Order III Rule 2, CPC – Acknowledges the holder of Power of Attorney as a person who acts for the party before the court.
- Section 47, CPC – Empowers the court executing the decree to decide questions related to the execution, discharge, or satisfaction of a decree.
- Section 151, CPC – Empowers the courts with inherent power to pass such orders in order to prevent abuse of the process of the court.
- Order XXI Rule 54, CPC – Deals with attachment of immovable property during execution proceedings.
- Section 48, Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 – Enumerates the narrow grounds on which enforcement of a foreign arbitral award can be denied.
Legal issue:
- Whether a person holding Power of Attorney can start and carry out execution proceedings in the name of a company.
- Whether a Board Resolution authorizing the execution proceedings was essential.
- Whether the lack of a Board Resolution impacted the validity of the Power of Attorney and the execution application.
- Whether the powers of a representative of a company could be questioned when execution proceedings have been ongoing for close to two decades.
- Whether a procedural irregularity relating to the powers of the representative can bar enforcement of the foreign arbitral award which is otherwise enforceable.
- Whether the executing Court is right in dismissing the application of the petitioner under Order III Rule 2 together with Sections 47 and 151 CPC.
- Whether the objections raised by the judgment debtor are delaying the enforcement of the foreign arbitral award.
Arguments of the Petitioner – M/s S.S. Exports
According to the arguments of the petitioner, it appeared that ARK Shipping Company had not furnished a resolution of its Board that it had authorised the execution process in India. Furthermore, according to the petitioner, there was a lack of proper documentation that would prove that the Board of directors of the company had authorised Mr. A.Z. Mookhtiar to be its Power of Attorney holder. As per the petitioner, unless the process is done through proper authority of the company, it will not stand in accordance with law. It was argued by the petitioner that the Executing Court failed to deal with the objections raised by the petitioner under Section 47 CPC.
Contentions of the Respondent – M/s ARK Shipping Co. Ltd.
The respondent contended that the proceedings for execution were started based on a valid Power of Attorney dated 6 September 2004, which was properly executed, notarized, apostille and stamping. The respondent contended that Order III Rule 2 CPC does not make it mandatory in all cases to produce Board Resolution along with the execution of the document. It further contended that the petitioners have taken part in the proceedings for execution since 2005 without raising any objection about the authorization of the power of attorney holder. The respondent further contended that this objection raised now after 21 years was just a mere ploy to delay the execution of the foreign award. Further, it was contended that all previous objections against the award were dismissed by the Karnataka High Court and the Supreme Court.
Analysis:
This ruling has been significant in striking the balance between the procedures involved and the fundamental right to receive justice. While it was rightly recognized that companies can operate through representatives, the lack of Board Resolution does not automatically make the process invalid in case there are other ways that can prove the authority of the parties involved. This ruling has also differentiated between the right to enforce an arbitral award and the procedure used in enforcing such right. Above all, it has recognized that procedural challenges can never become means to indefinitely delay justice. ARK Shipping had secured its award in 2005, and after over twenty years of litigation, it had still failed to enjoy any benefit from the award. This makes the ruling strengthen the finality of arbitration and also minimize unnecessary litigations. However, this does not mean that valid concerns regarding the authority of corporations can be overlooked. Procedural challenges that are raised on the basis of evidence must still be considered.
Conclusion
The Karnataka High Court rejected the writ petition of S.S. Exports and ordered that cost of Rs. 5 lakhs be paid to ARK Shipping within a period of four weeks. Furthermore, the court directed the Executing Court to give priority to the case, make no unnecessary adjournments and complete the execution process within a period of six months. This decision highlights the principle that procedural objections cannot be raised again and again to defeat the execution of an arbitral award from a foreign jurisdiction.
“PRIME LEGAL is a National Award-winning law firm with over two decades of experience across diverse legal sectors. We are dedicated to setting the standard for legal excellence in civil, criminal, and family law.”
Written by: Krittika Sengupta


