PRIME LEGAL | Independent Application of Mind and Scope of Investigative Powers under the Competition Act Orissa High Court Explains

November 20, 2026by Primelegal Team

Case Name: Competition Commission of India and Another v. M/S Rungta Mines Limited and Others

Case Number: Writ Appeal No. 909 of 2026

Date: 10 November 2026

Court: High Court of Orissa at Cuttack

Quorum: Chief Justice Harish Tandon and Justice Chittaranjan Dash

FACTS

The matter came up on account of the complaint filed on 6 March 2021 with the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) by the Coimbatore Corporation Contractors Welfare Association with allegations of cartelization and price fixing by some steel companies. The complaint was sent to the Director General (DG) of the Competition Commission of India (CCI) on 30 April 2021. The name of Rungta Mines Limited was not mentioned in the said complaint. On 29 July 2021, the Madras High Court ordered the DG to take action as per the law. Thereafter, the CCI instituted the case as Suo Motu Case No. 02 of 2021 and initiated the investigation. In the course of the investigation, the search was conducted at the Kolkata office of Rungta Mines from 16 December 2022 to 18 December 2022, and statements were recorded from its employees.

DG’s report was submitted on 5th January 2024. Thereafter, the CCI ordered further investigation, and further reports were submitted in April and August 2025, respectively. In August 2025, after inspection of the records of the CCI, it was found out that Rungta Mines had been declared as the Opposite Party.

Rungta Mines, along with its Whole-Time Director, filed a petition before the Orissa High Court challenging the investigation. The petition was allowed by the Single Judge on 22nd May 2026, whereby the investigation, along with the consequent proceedings, was quashed against Rungta Mines. Being aggrieved by the above order, the CCI and the DG have filed this appeal.

 

ISSUES

  • Is the writ petition maintainable u/s 226 of the Constitution in view of the existence of other remedies and issues relating to delay and premature filing of the writ?
  • Did the Orissa High Court have jurisdiction u/s 226(2) of the Constitution?
  • Could the decision of the Madras High Court be substituted for the statutory mandate of the formation of the prima facie opinion u/s 26(1) of the Competition Act, 2002?
  • Was the mind of the CCI properly applied before giving the direction for the investigation?
  • Could the DG investigate any other enterprise not mentioned in the complaint, and was the procedure for inclusion of Rungta Mines followed?

LEGAL PROVISIONS INVOLVED

  • Section 19 of the Competition Act, 2002 – Inquiry into certain agreements and dominant position of enterprises: Authorises the CCI to inquire into any agreement/abuse of dominance and to cause investigations thereinto either Suo motu or otherwise on receipt of information/referendum.
  • Section 26(1) of the Competition Act, 2002 – Procedure for inquiry: Directs the CCI to form a prima facie view about the existence of a case before directing the DG to investigate the same.
  • Section 26(3A) of the Competition Act, 2002: Authorises the CCI to order further investigation by the DG.
  • Section 53B of the Competition Act, 2002 – Appeals to the Appellate Tribunal: Deals with the provisions relating to appeal from an order/decision of the CCI to be filed before NCLAT.
  • Article 226: Provides power to issue writs for enforcing any fundamental right.
  • Article 141: Provides that the decision of the Supreme Court is binding on all Indian Courts.
  • Regulation 24 of the Competition Commission of India (General) Regulations, 2009: Provides the relevant procedure for impleading additional parties.

ARGUMENTS

APPLICANTS- The appellants pleaded that the initiation of the investigation by the CCI in accordance with Section 26(1) of the Act was done in accordance with the directions of the Honourable Madras High Court in its order dated 29 July 2021. They maintained that the DG is empowered to investigate such enterprises that have become parties to the case during the course of the investigation. They cited the cases of Competition Commission of India v. Steel Authority of India Ltd., (2010) 10 SCC 744 and Excel Crop Care Ltd. v. CCI, (2017) 8 SCC 47.

RESPONDENTS- According to the respondents, the CCI had failed to develop a prima facie view independently before conducting the investigation, in light of Section 26(1). They said that the order made by the Madras High Court was only a direction to act according to law and not a substitution for the duty of the CCI. According to the respondents, inclusion of Rungta Mines as an Opposite Party had been done without complying with Regulation 24 of the 2009 Regulations. They relied on MRF Ltd. v. Competition Commission of India, 2024 SCC OnLine Mad 2244, and Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala, (2000) 6 SCC 359.

ANALYSIS

The Court considered whether the CCI had made out its case based on the fulfilment of the necessary legal requirements before launching the inquiry. In this regard, the Court ruled that the Madras High Court’s order of 29 July 2021 had not discharged the necessity of taking an independent prima facie opinion under Section 26(1).

The Court referred to Competition Commission of India v. Steel Authority of India Ltd., where it was ruled that although the directions to conduct the inquiry were administrative in nature and did not entail any prior hearing, the CCI was to make certain observations indicating its deliberation. The minutes of the meeting on 23 August 2021 merely recorded that deliberation had been made in detail but failed to make any independent prima facie opinion.

In this regard, the Court has also scrutinised the matter of Excel Crop Care Ltd. v. CCI and Samir Agrawal v. Competition Commission of India, (2021) 3 SCC 136. It is pertinent to mention that while scrutinising this matter, the Court observed that though the DG has the power to investigate those enterprises which come up during a valid investigation, such power does not mean unlimited investigation of all the enterprises in the industry.

Furthermore, the Court observed that Rungta Mines has been made an Opposite Party without any specific order and also in violation of Regulation 24. It has also been stated that while giving permission for investigating other associations, no permission has been granted for investigating Rungta Mines. 

Thus, the Court observed that there has been a procedural deficiency and invalidity in terms of statutory basis in the said investigation.

JUDGMENT

Orissa High Court refused to grant the writ appeal instituted by the CCI and the DG on 10 November 2026. The order was consistent with the Single Judge’s decision delivered on 22 May 2026, setting aside the investigation and consequent proceedings taken against Rungta Mines Limited and its Whole-Time Director. The Court made it clear that while the DG had the jurisdiction to investigate another enterprise in case it came to his knowledge during the course of a valid investigation, such jurisdiction would have no statutory backing. The remedy was confined to the named parties only.

CONCLUSION

This decision stresses the need for adherence to legal procedures during investigation under the Competition Act, 2002. This case brings out the fact that the CCI has to independently form its opinion on prima facie grounds before taking action to investigate. The DG is also at liberty to investigate other companies, but this should not happen beyond the provisions of law. This decision helps maintain accountability during the process of investigation and also saves enterprises from any baseless proceedings.

 

“PRIME LEGAL is a National Award-winning law firm with over two decades of experience across diverse legal sectors. We are dedicated to setting the standard for legal excellence in civil, criminal, and family law.” 

WRITTEN BY- DEBARATI CHATTERJEE 

Competition Commission of India and Anr v. M.s Rungta Mines Limited and Ors