Case Name: Bull Agro Implements & Ors. v. Ashlyn Antony & Anr.
Case Number: OP (PT) No. 4 of 2024
Date of Judgment: 13 November 2026
Date of Hearing: 26 October 2026 (Reserved on this date)
Court: High Court of Judicature at Madras
Quorum: Hon’ble Mr. Justice P.B. Balaji
Facts:
The controversy arose as Ashlyn Antony got Patent No. 458805 on 12th October 2023 of an invention titled “Baler for tying round bale using twine”. In the invention, there is the use of a chain drive along with a side backstop clutch, together with a blade that cuts the twine upon reaching a predetermined density of the bale. Ashlyn Antony later sent out a cease-and-desist letter dated 22nd January 2024 against the Bull Agro Implements, accusing of them infringing the patented mechanism. Bull Agro filed a suit challenging the legality of the patent in the Madras High Court through Section 64 of the Patents Act, 1970, on the ground that the mechanisms used were already present in the agriculture machinery sector and thus the invention has no novelty and inventive step. There was an accusation of insufficient disclosure of the invention and also Bull Agro claimed that the invention was never commercially manufactured and sold by Ashlyn Antony. Bull Agro brought in 12 prior art documents to prove that the invention was not new.
Legal issues:
- Was there any prior knowledge of the invention which was patented before the date of priority of the patent claim?
- Was there a lack of novelty in the invention due to the existence of similar mechanical parts and mechanisms in the previous inventions?
- Did the combination of chain drive, side backstop clutch and density controlled cutting mechanism contain an inventive step or not?
- Was there adequate and fair description of the invention in the complete specification of the patent?
- Were the petitioners eligible for the revocation of the patent under Section 64 of the Patents Act, 1970?
- Can non-commercialisation or non-working of the invention be grounds for revocation?
Legal provisions :
- Section 2(1)(j): Invention: The invention must be new, have an inventive step and be capable of industrial application.
- Section 2(1)(t): Interested Person: Who may legally challenge the validity of a patent.
- Section 64(1)(d): Not an Invention: A patent may be revoked where its subject matter is not an invention according to the provisions of the Act.
- Section 64(1)(f): Lack of Inventive Step: A patent may be revoked where its invention is obvious and there is no inventiveness in it.
- Section 64(1)(h): Insufficient Disclosure: A patent may be revoked where its specification does not sufficiently disclose the invention and means of putting it into practice.
- Section 64(1)(i): Ambiguous Patent Claims: A patent may be revoked where its claims are ambiguous and/or not sufficiently described by the specification.
- Section 146(2): Working of Patented Invention: Provides that patentees are required to file annual statements concerning commercial working of their inventions in India.
- Rule 131: Filing of Form 27: Defines how and when patentees are supposed to file statements on commercial working of their inventions.
- Section 85(1): Revocation for Non-working. Specifies conditions upon which a patent is revoked after having obtained a compulsory licence on the grounds of non-working of the invention.
Analysis:
The Madras High Court looked into all 12 prior arts cited by Bull Agro and found that while certain components were already present in earlier inventions, none of them showed the combination claimed by Ashlyn Antony. The Court paid particular attention to the chain drive on the link plate, the side backstop clutch for holding the twine for the next cycle and the blade below the clutch, which cuts the twine when it reaches a predetermined density of the bales. The Court held that this particular combination brought about new technical advances and did not involve any obvious combination of the existing components. As regards insufficient disclosure, the Court noted that even the petitioners themselves understood the structure and function of the invention through their pleadings. Moreover, Claims 1 to 7 sufficiently described the features and functioning of the patented machine. The Court further rejected the claim of non-commercialization, noting that the relevant period for filing the working statement under Section 146(2) along with Rule 131 was yet to expire. It was made clear that non-working or non-marketing, alone could not be the ground for revocation under Section 64.
Conclusion
The Madras High Court rejected the revocation petition filed by Bull Agro Implements and affirmed the patent granted to Ashlyn Antony. The Court observed that the presence of certain components in prior art inventions cannot necessarily render an invention non-novel simply because the specific combination of such elements results in technical advancement and meets the criteria for a patent. Furthermore, the Court held that the invention was inventive, industrially applicable and sufficiently described in the complete specification. Moreover, the petitioners were unable to prove that the patent could be revoked on grounds of insufficient disclosure and unclear claims. In addition, it was made clear by the Court that non-commercial manufacture or marketing of a patented invention will not render the patent invalid under Section 64. Accordingly, being satisfied that the petition did not have any merit, the Court rejected the petition without any cost order.
“PRIME LEGAL is a National Award-winning law firm with over two decades of experience across diverse legal sectors. We are dedicated to setting the standard for legal excellence in civil, criminal, and family law.”
WRITTEN BY: Krittika Sengupta


