Regional Faiths Matter: Calcutta HC Reserves Judgment on Kali Puja PIL

October 30, 2024by Primelegal Team0
religions.jpg

INTRODUCTION

A Calcutta High Court vacation bench has remarked that since religious practices in East India differ from those in North India, it would not be realistic to call for a restriction of practices that may have formed an “essential religious practice” for many communities. The high court bench while hearing the plea by Akhil Bharatiya Go Sevak Sangh against the alleged sacrifice of animals on the occasion of Bolla Kali Puja, remarked that it is controversial whether mythical characters were vegetarian or non-vegetarian.

 

BACKGROUND

The Calcutta High Court in a recent order has refused to grant any interim relief in a plea seeking a blanket restriction on practice of alleged animal sacrifice at Kolkata’s Bolla Kali Temple on the occasion of “Bolla Kali Puja.”

The high court bench while hearing the plea by Akhil Bharatiya Go Sevak Sangh against the alleged sacrifice of animals on the occasion of Bolla Kali Puja, remarked that it is controversy whether mythical characters were vegetarian or non-vegetarian, a LiveLaw report said. 

The bench of Justices Biswajit Basu and Ajay Kumar Gupta said that since religious practices in East India differ from those in North India, it would not be realistic to call for a restriction of practices which may have become an essential religious practice for many communities, the report said.

The high court said that it could not order such a restriction as it would be impossible to implement. It further said that without hearing the case at length, the bench cannot grant interim relief. The matter has been listed for further hearing post Diwali break before a regular bench. The Puja however is scheduled for Friday.

A similar plea was filed before the high court last year as well against alleged sacrifice of 10,000 goats in the Kali Temple on occasion of Bolla Kali Puja.

However, another bench of Chief Justice TS Sivagananam had refused an interim stay but had agreed to consider the larger question of the validity of animal sacrifice in West Bengal, the report said.

The village Bolla is situated 20 km away from Balurghat town on the Balurghat – Malda Highway. The village is home to an historical temple, where Hindu goddess Maa Kali is worshiped by the devotees.

The main Kali Puja is held on each Friday after the day of Rash Purnima. Huge number of devotees, from different parts of the South Dinajpur district, gather in the temple during the Puja and offer prayers. A three-day fair is organized by the Puja committee on this occasion.

 

KEY ASPECTS

  • PIL: Akhil Bharatiya Go Sevak Sangh filed a PIL seeking a ban on animal sacrifice at Kolkata’s Bolla Kali Temple on the occasion of “Bolla Kali Puja.

 

  • Refusal of immediate ban: The HC declined to hear the iimeadiate ban stating to the significance of religious practices.

 

  • Regional Religious Practices: The court closely observed and stated that the religious practices change from region to region. The bench of Justices Biswajit Basu and Ajay Kumar Gupta  said that since religious practices in East India differ from those in North India, it would not be realistic to call for a restriction of practices which may have become an essential religious practice for many communities, the report said.

 

CONCLUSION 

Overall, the court in this case highlighted the importance of cultural and regional differences in religious practices. Understanding the complexities of the case, the bench ruled causing no harm to anyone or any religious practices. 

 

“PRIME LEGAL is a full-service law firm that has won a National Award and has more than 20 years of experience in an array of sectors and practice areas. Prime legal falls into the category of best law firm, best lawyer, best family lawyer, best divorce lawyer, best divorce law firm, best criminal lawyer, best criminal law firm, best consumer lawyer, best civil lawyer.”

 

WRITTEN BY: D.V. DEEKSHA.

Primelegal Team

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *